As the new version of The Mummy, starring Tom Cruise and Sofia Boutella as the title character, opened to scathing reviews this past week, I noticed a trend of reviewers referencing the 1999 version of the film, and several critics urging people to just go and rewatch the 1999 version of The Mummy instead of watching the new version. As the 1999 version also happens to star a reel librarian in a lead role (Rachel Weisz as Evelyn “Evie” Carnahan, a librarian and Egyptologist), I thought it a perfect opportunity to follow their advice!
Snippets from current reviews of the new version of The Mummy which reference the 1999 version:
- “But alas, The Mummy turns out to be a drab, nonsensical affair that squanders its potential for humor, atmosphere, and sweep — qualities that the much-maligned, Fraser-starring 1999 Mummy had in droves.” (from The Village Voice)
- “No one over the age of 10 ever confused them [Universal’s film archive of monsters] with good movies, but the “Mummy” franchise that kicked off in 1999 had a joyously sinister and farfetched eye-candy pizzazz.” (from Variety)
- “[I]f you want to watch a fun Mummy movie this weekend, the newest option isn’t your safest bet.” (from Rotten Tomatoes)
And finally, the review from Vox, which sums up its review of the new version with this takeaway:
“The Mummy is playing nationwide. You would be better off watching the 1999 version, and I don’t even like that movie.“
But I do!
I still find The Mummy (1999) a fun adventure film, tongue firmly in cheek, and winking at its own spectacle; I agree with IndieWire, which called it “enduringly delightful.” I must admit two biases up front: (1) I have always been a fan of genre films that commit unabashedly to their genres, like the 1999 version does (not so much the sequels), and (2) I love films with meaty reel librarian roles. Because OF COURSE. Especially reel librarians who kick ass onscreen and win at camel races. 😉
Oh, and SPOILERS.
If you need a reminder of the plot, here’s a trailer for the 1999 version:
In this adventure, Egyptian priest Imhotep is accidentally brought back to life. Egyptology librarian Evelyn (Rachel Weisz), her brother (John Hannah), and an American soldier (Brendan Fraser) join forces to stop Imhotep.
Here’s a look at my original notes from when I first analyzed the film (and yes, I initially misspelled Rachel Weisz’s name in those notes, mea culpa):
I could go in many different directions in analyzing this film, but I’m going to stay in the direction these early notes took me: focusing on Evie’s reel librarian role and how that role evolved. Even in this one snapshot from my notes, you can see my scrawled notes describing her character and how Evie’s character evolves on screen:
- “quiet at first but becomes forceful by end”
- “wants to move up”
Evie is one of the lead characters of the film, and her character arc fulfills the role of Liberated Librarians. Let’s check off the hallmarks of a Liberated Librarian that connect and describe Evie’s character and role in the film:
- A naïve, inexperienced woman who discovers herself—and what she’s capable of—in face of an adventure/disaster
- Her “liberation” is intertwined with the major plot — the discoveries of the “Book of the Dead” and the “Book of Amun-Ra” mirror her own self-discovery
- Young in age
- Clothing more conservative and buttoned-up at first
- Undergoes a change of appearance, dressing more feminine and more exotic (and her hair comes down from its bun!)
The scene in which we meet Evie comes early in the film, after the introduction that sets up Imhotep’s backstory. The library scene takes place in the Museum of Antiquities in Cairo, Egypt, and Evie is on a tall ladder and shelving books. While trying to take a shortcut to shelve a wayward title, she accidentally topples all the bookcases in the library. (One of the lessons learned in this film? Don’t take shortcuts while shelving books!) Also, during the commentary of this scene on the DVD, director Stephen Sommers reveals that they got this scene in one take!
As director Sommers also states on the DVD commentary:
“We learn everything we need to know about Evie and her backstory without it seeming like lame exposition.”
From her light sparring with the museum director, as seen in the clip above, we also learn this crucial characteristic at the heart of this reel librarian character: She stands up for herself when others directly challenge her. However else she changes, and her story arc evolves, this remains true. She also knows her own intelligence, and that her intelligence is an asset.
“I am proud of what I am. I am a librarian.”
One of the major ways that Evie’s character breaks from the Liberated Librarian character type is that unlike most Liberated Librarians, Evie is committed to and proud of her profession.
This is most apparent in the (in)famous scene around the campfire in which Evie is inebriated, as seen in the clip below. (I also highlighted this scene and quote in a previous Quotable Librarian post.)
“Look, I may not be an explorer, or an adventurer, or a treasure seeker, or a gun fighter… But I am proud of what I am. I… am a librarian!”
However much I love this rallying cry — “I am a librarian!” — I do think she undersells herself in this moment. She has already proven onscreen that she is indeed an explorer and an adventurer, and she shot a gun in a skirmish just minutes before this campfire scene. It is true, however, that it is her brother (played by the cheeky John Hannah) who is the treasure seeker.
The power of reading:
Evie also underestimates the power of reading. And from a librarian, too — for shame! But it sets the rest of the movie in motion, and serves as another way to highlight how she evolves over the course of the film.
In another campfire scene, after she has discovered the “Book of the Dead,” she figures out how to open the book and starts to read from it.
“It’s just a book. No harm ever came from reading a book.”
Yeah… except by doing so, she conjures up the mummy. (Next time, maybe try reading silently first.) The other Egyptologist, played by veteran Australian actor Jonathan Hyde, knows the danger, but he is too late in shouting, “No! You must not read from the book!“
In a word, “Oops.”
This is a cautionary tale enveloped within an adventure story. Reading = Power.
Reel librarian hero:
The hero in the story who got all the attention at the time was Brendan Fraser as American soldier Rick O’Connell. But the real hero in this story, in my opinion, is Evie.
Here’s evidence from the film to back that up:
- Evie saves Rick from hanging in an Egyptian prison by negotiating his release — and setting the plot in motion to find Hamunaptra, the city of the dead
- She saves Rick’s life again on the boat, by pulling him aside from a spray of bullets (this is a clever bit, as she sees the pattern of gunshots along the wall and anticipates that Rick is in the way — demonstrating that she’s not just book smart!)
- She beats Rick at camel racing
- She figures out the solution to reverse the curse is to find the Book of Amun-Ra AND figures out where the Book of Amun-Ra is buried
- Evie sacrifices herself to Imhotep in order to save her friends
- She helps her brother translate the Book of Amun-Ra while SHE HERSELF is fighting off a mummy — thinking in action!
- She helps make Imhotep mortal so that Rick can finish him off
Evie is the one who (accidentally) conjured the curse, so following standard hero-story arcs, she therefore has to be the one to figure out how to solve it. And she does. She comes through stronger in the end, further highlighting her intelligence and resilience.
However, Evie is never called a hero in this story by others. Instead, there are a variety of phrases and terms, often unflattering, that other characters use to describe Evie, including:
- “Compared to you, the other plagues were a joy”
- “damsel in distress”
- “not a total loss”
- “old Mum”
But instead of dwelling on those less-than-flattering descriptions, let’s instead focus on appreciating Evie and the actress who first brought her to life in The Mummy (1999):
I came across this fun fact that I came across while reading the film’s trivia on IMDb.com:
When King Tutankhamen’s tomb was found on November 4, 1922, the person in charge was George Herbert, 5th Earl of Carnarvon. Along with him was his daughter, Lady Evelyn Carnarvon. Rachel Weisz’s character is named Evelyn Carnahan. Originally, her character was meant to be Evelyn Carnarvon. She and her brother were to be the children of the “cursed” Lord Carnarvon. The only evidence of this left in the film is in the line where Evelyn tells O’Connell that her father was a “very, very famous explorer”. The Mummy novelization goes into a bit more detail on her back story.
Amazing! Here’s a picture of Lady Evelyn Carnarvon with her father at King Tut’s tomb in 1922:
You can see more pics and read more about the real-life inspiration for Evie’s character here on this site.
And one final fun fact: the ancestral Carnarvon home is none other than Highclere Castle — which served as the locale for Downton Abbey in the TV series! The website for Highclere Castle even has a whole section dedicated to its Egyptian connection.
I thoroughly enjoyed this trip down Mummy memory lane and learning more along the way. Hope you did, too!
Next week, I will be back with a post about another adventurer librarian!
- Cross, William. “Lady Evelyn Herbert: The First Woman to Enter Old King Tut’s Tomb.” Lady Evelyn Herbert, 13 Sept. 2016.
- Ebiri, Bilge. “Why Is Tom Cruise In ‘The Mummy’?” The Village Voice, 7 June 2017.
- “The Egyptian Exhibition.” Highclere Castle, n.d.
- Ehrlich, David. “Review: ‘The Mummy’ Is The Worst Tom Cruise Movie Ever.” IndieWire, 7 June 2017.
- Giles, Jeff. “The Mummy Should Have Stayed Buried.” Rotten Tomatoes, 8 June 2017.
- Gleiberman, Owen. “Film Review: Tom Cruise in ‘The Mummy’.” Variety, 9 June 2017.
- The Mummy. Dir. Stephen Sommers. Perf. Brendan Fraser, Rachel Weisz, John Hannah, Arnold Vosloo. Universal, 1999.
- “Trivia.” The Mummy (1999), Internet Movie Database.
- VanDerWerff, Todd. “The Mummy Says More about its Stars and its Franchise than Anything Mummy-Related.” Vox, 9 June 2017.